HOME INSIDER'S GUIDES PRICES AND SPECS REVIEWS ON THE INSIDE CARS FOR SALE

Reviews > User Reviews > Volkswagen > Golf (1998-05) Details

User Reviews

Volkswagen Golf (1998-05)

Disagree with the reviews below? Tell us what you think.

Version

1.6 SE Auto 5dr Hatchback

Author

Ben Johnson

Overall Rating

2 stars

I am so disappointed! I've only done 50k miles in it, and by 25k I had to replace: driver's electric window, music centre, a/c, central arm rest, and fuel management system! It is also very thirsty.

Star Ratings

Handling

3 stars

Comfort

3 stars

Quality & Reliability

1 stars

Performance

2 stars

Roominess

3 stars

Running Costs

1 stars

Value for Money

2 stars

Stereo/Sat Nav

3 stars
 

Version

Mk4 Golf 1.8 GTI T / 51 plate

Author

Charlie

Overall Rating

5 stars

This is the 7th car that I have owned. The other cars ranging from a Pug 306 too a Subaru Impreza Sport. Out of all of these cars I'd have to say the GTI T is the best of the lot. If you cant get comfortable in the seats then there is something clearly wrong with you, there are lots of different settings. Build quality as you'd expect from a Vw is fantastic. Acceleration very quick. I cannot find a fault with this car. I have managed to get as a general rule kicking around 350 miles to a tank even with some hard acceleration... If your thinking about buying one, go for a test drive ... im fairly certain you will fall in love with it... I did...

Star Ratings

Handling

4 stars

Comfort

5 stars

Quality & Reliability

5 stars

Performance

5 stars

Roominess

5 stars

Running Costs

3 stars

Value for Money

4 stars

Stereo/Sat Nav

4 stars
 

Version

3dr 1.8 GTi T

Author

Dave

Overall Rating

3 stars

I agree with Euan, regardless of adjustments, I can just not get comfortable in my Golf! Either the steering wheel is too close but the pedals are too far away, or the steering is too far away and the pedals are too close. Also the steering on mine is s***. There is so much play its unreal, i dont know if anyone else has this problem... Also does anyone else find the gears crunch now and again. The Recaroes also get in the way of changing gear

Star Ratings

Handling

2 stars

Comfort

2 stars

Quality & Reliability

3 stars

Performance

3 stars

Roominess

4 stars

Running Costs

3 stars

Value for Money

3 stars

Stereo/Sat Nav

3 stars
 

Version

1.8T GTI 5dr Hatchback

Author

Euan Stephen

Overall Rating

3 stars

In general this car is good and I have had no problems with it for the 2 years I have owned it. My only gripe would be that I just can't find a seating position that is comfortable.

Star Ratings

Handling

3 stars

Comfort

3 stars

Quality & Reliability

4 stars

Performance

4 stars

Roominess

3 stars

Running Costs

4 stars

Value for Money

4 stars

Stereo/Sat Nav

3 stars
 

Version

1.9 TDi

Author

Kevin

Overall Rating

5 stars

If you can't get a comfortable driving position you are very odd. I've never seen so much adjustment.

Star Ratings

Handling

5 stars

Comfort

5 stars

Quality & Reliability

5 stars

Performance

5 stars

Roominess

5 stars

Running Costs

5 stars

Value for Money

5 stars

Stereo/Sat Nav

5 stars
 

Version

GT TDI 130

Author

M Gother

Overall Rating

4 stars

My 02 plate Golf GT TDI 130 is a fantastic car to drive, and you do feel safe in it. It is one of the few cars where you get performance and economy. It's also very reliable. If you're thinking of buying one, shop around for one that has all the toys like climate control and cruise control. Servicing and parts are expensive; and my advice is avoid the long-life service - it seems to last the same time as a normal service and costs 50% more. And if you're not bothered about the badge, buy a SEAT Leon - it's essentially the same car but cheaper because Golf prices are a lot higher than price guides suggest.

Star Ratings

Handling

4 stars

Comfort

4 stars

Quality & Reliability

5 stars

Performance

5 stars

Roominess

3 stars

Running Costs

2 stars

Value for Money

3 stars

Stereo/Sat Nav

2 stars
 

Version

1.9SDi

Author

Michael Verner

Overall Rating

3 stars

Have had to replace a pulley wheel in connection with timing belt, a brake light switch, back brake discs (x2) all within 70,000 miles. I expected more from a VW and I am a very easy driver.

Star Ratings

Handling

4 stars

Comfort

4 stars

Quality & Reliability

3 stars

Performance

2 stars

Roominess

3 stars

Running Costs

3 stars

Value for Money

2 stars

Stereo/Sat Nav

1 stars
 

Version

1.6S 5dr Hatchback

Author

Michelle Debono

Overall Rating

3 stars

Great looking car with lots of room. Air con, e/w, c/l and s/r all make it excellent value. However, this is the worst VW I have owned... It is the second I have bought from new and has been very disappointing. Brakes are awful, gearchange is notchy and it's had to go in a couple of times for minor things. Go for the Mark 3 - it's much better.

Star Ratings

Handling

4 stars

Comfort

4 stars

Quality & Reliability

1 stars

Performance

4 stars

Roominess

4 stars

Running Costs

4 stars

Value for Money

4 stars

Stereo/Sat Nav

4 stars
 

Version

1.9 GT TDI 130 3dr

Author

Paul D

Overall Rating

5 stars

I've owned this car from new - 5 years and 2 months now. It has been the most reliable Golf I've ever owned (this is my seventh Golf!). It does 50+mpg. I've never had any problems that needed attention from the dealer - I've only paid for regular servicing and tyres. I've never even had to replace a bulb... Overall, very good.

Star Ratings

Handling

4 stars

Comfort

5 stars

Quality & Reliability

5 stars

Performance

5 stars

Roominess

5 stars

Running Costs

5 stars

Value for Money

5 stars

Stereo/Sat Nav

5 stars
 

Version

1.8 GTi 5dr hatch

Author

Russ Thomas

Overall Rating

4 stars

Owned for 3 years; reliable apart from air mass meter, but most things work well. Comfortable although noisy on M roads. Not cheap to run, and depreciation has been higher than I was led to believe.

Star Ratings

Handling

3 stars

Comfort

4 stars

Quality & Reliability

3 stars

Performance

2 stars

Roominess

3 stars

Running Costs

3 stars

Value for Money

3 stars

Stereo/Sat Nav

3 stars