Reviews - BMW

Overall Rating

Second generation Compact is a class act. It's just as desirable as its saloon sister, styling and quality are top notch, and its unique rear-drive hatchback layout pleases keen drivers.

• Sporty hatchback coupe with strong image
• Refined and responsive with pin-sharp steering
• Quality cabin and good standard equipment

• Quite pricey, new and used
• Rear headroom could be better
• Extras push up prices rapidly

The original Compact seemed a bit of an afterthought a 3-Series with the boot sawn off, that was never ranked equally with other 3's. The current generation completely revises those views. It's a classic sports hatch whose rear-wheel driving characteristics combine with a brilliant chassis and fine engines to produce a car that handles with supreme confidence and is also fun. No Compact is cheap new prices start at around £17,000 and extras hike the bill far higher but the least expensive 316ti is a sound choice if you don't need the 325ti's 7-second 0-60mph acceleration. The 316 has a modern 1.8-litre Valvetronic engine, develops 115bhp, gives 40mpg and offers smooth, flexible power across the rev range. The cabin is efficiently styled, with a good driving position and adequate rear legroom although rear headroom is restricted. And lesser rivals are better equipped; climate control costs nearly £1000 on basic versions.

Best Models: Cheap 316ti and frugal 320td

Worst Models: Pricey 325ti Sport

Replacement: 2005

• Audi A3 (2003-)
• Mercedes-Benz C Class Sport
• Toyota Celica (1999-)